Monday, June 20, 2005

Amen, Bob Herbert

Great Editorial today, especially this section:

"Last week's New York Times/CBS News Poll found that the mounting casualties and continuing turmoil in Iraq have made Americans increasingly pessimistic about the war. A majority said the U.S. should have stayed out of Iraq and only 37 percent approved of the president's handling of the war.

What hasn't changed is the fact that the vast majority of the parents who support the war do not want their children to fight it. A woman in the affluent New York suburb of Ridgewood, N.J., who has a daughter in high school and a younger son, said: "I would not want my children to go. If there wasn't a war it would be different. I support the war and I think we need to be there. But it's not going well. It's becoming like Vietnam. It's a very bad situation. But we can't leave."

I don't know how you win a war that your country doesn't want to fight. We sent too few troops into Iraq in the first place and the number of warm bodies available for Iraq and other military missions going forward is dwindling alarmingly. The Bush crowd may be bellicose, but for most Americans the biggest contribution to the war effort is a bumper sticker that says "support our troops," and maybe a belligerent call to a talk radio station..."


Support the "theoretical" troops, but mostly support my child doing something else, so some other sucker can lose the bet.

And what are these troops fighting for?

I know the bromide "for our freedoms" is constantly trotted out, but what freedom in particular is being fought for in Iraq? The freedom of buying cheap sentiment made in China?

Or perhaps just this:

[Leslie] Gelb was scathing about America efforts to train an Iraqi army. ''If you ask any Iraqi leader, they will tell you these people can't fight. They just aren't trained. And yet we're cranking them out like rabbits." As for plans to train a 10 division Iraqi army by next year, Gelb was scathing. ''It became very apparent to me that these 10 divisions were to fight some future war against Iran. It had nothing to do, nothing to do," with taking Iraq over from the Americans and fighting the insurgents.


So, our troops are fighting a holding action until step 2 in C-Plus Augustus next Holy Clusterfuck?

Atrios is right, this would be a good topic for Scott McClellan to be made to lie about at the gaggle.

No comments: